Shopping for Fake Diamond Rings

Megan Coward
Paloma .5ct Round Brilliant Cut Antique Reproduction Ring at
Antique Reproduction Ring

With the cost of diamonds being high, costume or fake diamonds have become quite popular. Fake diamonds are simulants or imitations, which are materials intended to look like or imitate a diamond. Popular diamond simulants are cubic zirconia, moissanite, and even glass or plastic. Diamond simulants can be good options for couples looking for an affordable yet stylish engagement ring.

Where to Find Imitation Diamond Rings

Many reputable retailers carry fake diamond rings that are made from high quality materials and closely resemble an actual diamond. If you're looking for an engagement ring made with fake diamonds, start with these retailers.

Diamonique From QVC

QVC offers the Diamonique jewelry collection, featuring cubic zirconias (CZs). The Diamonique brand offers a range of different ring designs from simple to ornate, including engagement rings with a matching wedding band. The rings are fabricated from sterling silver, 14k white and yellow gold, or gold and platinum clad, which is a thin layer of 14k gold or platinum over sterling silver. Rings are priced from about $50 to $300.

QVC offers a 30-day money back guarantee on their jewelry.

  • The Eternal Love ring features a round cubic zirconia centered in a 14k yellow gold ring with more CZs set through the shank of the ring. The ring retails for around $250 and is also available in 14k white gold.
  • The Epiphany Bridal Ring Set features a three-stone setting with cushion cut cubic zirconias centered in a platinum clad ring with a split shank. There is also a matching wedding eternity band with cubic zirconia stones. The ring and band are sold together and retail for around $100.

Consumer review hub SiteJabber gives QVC an average rating of 4.5 out of five stars, noting their reliable shipping and easy return policy.

Moissanite Co. Rings

Moissanite Co. has many elaborate ring designs with multiple moissanite stones set in both modern and vintage-inspired styles. Options include traditional solitaires as well as artistic designs. The company carries rings with pave bands, split shanks, cathedral-style settings and more. Most rings are priced over $1000.

Moissanite Co. offers free ground shipping on orders over $200. They recommend contacting them about returns within 30 days of purchase. Allow up to ten days to process your order.

  • This antique reproduction ring features a round moissanite set in a 14k white or yellow ring, though you can opt for an old European cut stone for the same price. The matching wedding band is available for about $300. The ring retails around $450.
  • This halo style ring offers an emerald cut moissanite set in a 14k white, yellow, or rose gold ring surrounded by round diamond side stones. Specify millimeter size of the emerald cut when ordering. The ring retails from around $900 to $2,500 based on the size of the center stone chosen.

This company receives mixed reviews for customer service though most customers agree that the product is exceptional. They note the shine and settings of the rings they've purchased as especially impressive.

Moissanite by Charles & Colvard

At Moissanite by Charles & Colvard you can find rings in solitaire and multiple stone designs. Available stone shapes include round, princess, oval, heart, cushion and triangle. Most styles are priced between $500 and $2000. The Charles & Colvard Certificate of Authenticity and a limited lifetime warranty come with each ring.

The company offers a 30-day return policy on all items ordered. Items are shipped within five to ten days unless otherwise noted in the product description.

  • The Round Forever three stone ring features a round moissanite centered in a 14k white mounting with one round moissanites on each side. The split shank features small round diamonds that give the ring extra sparkle. The ring retails for around $1,400.
  • The Cushion Cut Solitaire ring is a delicate piece that features a square cut moissanite framed by round moissanites that are also accenting the shank of the ring. The ring is available in 14k white, yellow, or rose gold. The ring is priced at just over $800.

Charles & Colvard has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, and the few customer complaints listed there have all been resolved to the customers' satisfaction.

Less Expensive Options

Fashion jewelry featuring fake diamonds can be found at many retailers including department stores. If you're in the market for costume rings or just something a little less pricey, try one of these options.

JC Penney Fashion Jewelry

JC Penney has a selection of very inexpensive fashion rings designed to look similar to diamond rings. With most under $50, you can find ones to match your style and budget. Some rings are sterling silver and feature cubic zirconia while others feature crystal stones and are set in brass.

JC Penney offers a 60-day return policy that requires you to have the original receipt for your item. Many rings are limited in available sizes online though you can visit one of their retail stores for a wider selection.

  • The DiamondArt Cushion Bridal Set ring includes a cushion cut CZ in a halo of round CZs, set in a sterling silver ring. It's a showy piece that is sure to draw attention. The ring retails for about $160.
  • The Cubic Zirconia Solitaire Ring features a round CZ set in a white, silver-plated metal with round CZs through the shank. It's a classic design with lots of sparkle. The ring retails for about $30.

As a department store chain JC Penney has locations around the country, so returns or exchanges can be made in-store or online. Reviewers at SiteJabber note that shopping online at JC Penney offers the same high level of customer service as you would expect in-store.

Emitations CZ Rings

Emitations has a collection of low-cost cubic zirconia rings, including celebrity-inspired rings, antique designs, solitaires and wedding sets. Options include celebrity replica ring styles inspired by engagement rings belonging to stars like Jessica Simpson, Angelina Jolie, Jennifer Aniston and Princess Diana. All rings are set in sterling silver and most are priced between $20 and $70.

Emitations offers free shipping on orders over $75 and a 60-day return policy with exchange options.

  • Ellie's Silvertone Emerald Step Cut ring is an eternity band that features emerald cut cubic zirconia in a sterling silver mounting plated with rhodium. It can be stacked with other eternity rings for a brilliant presentation. The ring sells for around $60.
  • Carrie's Round Cut Black CZ Ring features a round, black cubic zirconia surrounded by round CZs that also adorn the shank of the ring. The ring is fabricated from sterling silver and imitates the ring given to Carrie by Mr. Big in the movie Sex and the City 2. It retails for about $75.

Reviewers at Shopper Approved give Emitations an overwhelmingly positive score with a five out of five star rating. They point out the easy site navigation and low prices as highlights of this retailer.

Fantasy Jewelry Box

Fantasy Jewelry Box features cubic zirconia rings in antique, classic and modern styles. Most designs are priced under $60 and set in sterling silver. You can find rings with simple single stones, three stone designs, large and flashy center stones, as well as ones mixed with other gemstones.

Fantasy Jewelry Box features free shipping on orders over $75 and a 30-day return policy. They often offer a free pair of earrings with orders over $50.

  • Isabella's Antique-Inspired Engagement Ring features a round cubic zirconia in a rhodium electroplated that features vintage details like milgrain edging and inlaid round diamonds on the band. The ring retails for about $50.
  • The Grace Sterling Silver CZ Ring offers a square shaped cubic zirconia in a sterling silver, rhodium plated mounting with round CZs on each side. The ring retails around $30.

This company has been featured in a variety of magazines, from Bridal Guide to Woman's World, in spreads that highlight their affordable options.

Fake Diamond Shopping Tips

When considering a fake diamond ring, keep the following tips in mind:

  • Shop for a spare: If you don't want to wear your real engagement ring on a trip or outing, consider getting a costume one to wear in its place. You can often find a similar design to the ring you have with a much lower price tag.
  • Consider the setting: Just because the stone you are purchasing is not a natural diamond doesn't mean that you need to skimp on the setting of the ring. Fake diamonds can be set in precious metals such as gold and in stylish settings. When shopping for a ring, keep this in mind and if you decide later to replace the stone, you can often keep the same setting.

  • Be honest: Never try to pass off an imitation diamond as a real one when giving an engagement ring. This can hurt your future spouse and make a lasting impression. Make sure that you both agree on using a costume ring for your engagement ring and choose something that you both will be happy with.

Imitations Are Worth Considering

There are plenty of reasons to choose an imitation diamond for an engagement ring or other piece of jewelry. There's no need to be embarrassed about buying or wearing an imitation diamond since they can often resemble a natural diamond and have numerous benefits that can make them quite appealing.

Shopping for Fake Diamond Rings